The Cake Lady Custom Cakes

St. Lucie, Martin & Indian River Counties

About this vendor

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes is a seasoned confectionery situated in Fort Pierce, FL. We promise to exceed your expectations with the highest standards in quality, taste, and design. We pride ourselves on working with great style, innovation, and creativity. Our cakes make beautiful, unique, and eye-catching centerpieces that will be the talk of your party. We specialize in and love creating wedding, party, anniversary, graduation, birthday, retirement, novelty, bridal shower, baby shower, baby reveal, special event, and guest-of-honor cakes. All our products are tailored to our client's wishes and style. If there is a special occasion, we can make a special cake, just for your event. We not only make fantastic and beautiful cakes, we also make chocolates, cupcakes, specialty cookies, cake pops, chocolate covered fruits and pretzels, as well as beautiful petit fours.

Details

Business Attributes

Woman-owned Business

Cakes & Desserts

Cake Accessories
Cake Serving Sets
Cake Stands
Cake Table Decorations
Cake Toppers
Cake Delivery & Setup

Dietary Options

Gluten Free
Nut Free
Sugar Free

4.8

out of 5.0

23 reviews

Search reviews

Taylor C

We used Staci for our four tier wedding cake this past weekend and everything was phenomenal. She works with you every step of the way to ensure your event is everything you want a...

nd more! She even worked with us so we can have our cake tasting in her shop because we live a little further away. The cake was beautiful, and was mind blowing delicious. We recommend the apple pie flavor ;)

Kayla H

Our cake was absolutely delicious from The Cake Lady! We did a 2 tier cake for me and my husband to cut and then we had 3 sheet cakes in the back. We picked Fig & Vanilla, White Ch...

ocolate Raspberry, and Lemon Strawberry for our flavors and they were to die for. The tasting was so much fun, she had so many flavors to choose from. The design of our cake was amazing. We gave her a little bit of an idea of what we wanted and she was able to create something we couldn't even imagine! Everything was perfect and I would hire her again and again.

Caitlin H

Staci did a phenomenal job! The cake looked exactly like I wanted it, it tasted DELICIOUS, and the assorted desserts were a huge hit! There were barely any left after only an hour ...

into the reception! Highly recommend!

Sarah R

Staci did an absolutely amazing job with our wedding cake and the grooms cake! The design of each was exactly what we wanted, and most of all the cake was probably the best cake I'...

ve ever had, and I've had a lot of cake. Both cakes were fresh, moist, and the frosting that perfect sweetness level. Everyone at our wedding was so complimentary of the cakes, and we can't wait for our anniversary to eat the top layer we kept. In fact, we may just order another one around that time because it was so good! I highly recommend Staci "The Cake Lady" for your wedding or any event requiring cake.

Lisa F

Stacy and her son were amazing. We went in for cupcake testing and she made us feel like family. On our wedding day, seeing our cake and how the cupcakes were set up just blew us a...

way. My sweet husband wanted a cake that looked like a tree stump and it came out perfect. We are still hearing about how good the cupcakes were. She is truly wonderful! Thank you!! Mr. & Mrs. French

Terri M

Staci is a true professional and such an amazing talent. From our 1st meeting , to the tasting, to the wedding day, our experience was nothing short of perfect! Our wedding cake wa...

s so beautiful and delicious ! I couldn't be happier. 10 STARS!!!!! From now on any cake order will go to The Cake Lady Custom Cakes.

Jennifer R

5 stars!! Ordered my wedding cake with Miss Staci. She runs herself, her team and her business in a professional manner. She is honest, sweet, and caring. You can tell right off th...

e bat that Miss Staci is very passionate with her work and she KNOWS her stuff! Her store smells of sweetness even outside of her storefront with the door closed, you can still smell the sweets!!

Chris G

Staci and her wonderful staff do an amazing job with not only producing beautiful cakes, pastries and confections they work extremely well with our community. I am a culinary arts ...

instructor at a local high school and Staci and her staff have never hesitated to lend a helping hand to the students interested in the baking and pastry industry. Staci and her staff are of the highest caliber of professionals with wonderful creative spirits always looking for a challenge. I would recommend them to any couple looking to have a wonderful experience and an amazing tasting cake at their wedding or event. Chef G-Balaschak

Jennifer B

Jennifer B I don't normally write reviews but in this case I felt I needed to share one of the most delicious wedding cakes I've ever tasted. I was recently at a wedding in Stuart...

Florida and had one of the most delicious cakes . I had to find out who made it. I found out it was a cute little shop in Fort Pierce The Cake Lady. I will definitely have my next big event cake made by The Cake Lady.

Nicole H

The Cake lady outdoes herself every time we order a cake. It started with our wedding cake, now she provides a cake for our kids’ birthdays every year! Highly recommend to anyone w...

ho asks.

Christine I

I have been buying cakes from The Cake Lady for seven or eight years! Staci is a true professional and her cakes are beautiful and delicious! She is an amazing artist!

Linda S

The Cake Lady has made numerous cakes for us. The people always rave about them and how creative and unique and delicious they are. Also, the owner Staci is funny and charming to w...

ork with!

Gabrielle W

The flavors were amazing and she decorated it perfectly with the real flowers our florist provided.

Lara V

Staci’s cake was beautiful and tasted SO good! We did end up saving the top tier but other than that there was none left over at the end of the weekend. Guests said it was the best...

wedding cake they ever had. Highly recommend!

Melissa M

The cupcakes and cake were delicious. So good in fact that even though I was concerned we might have some left over, my husband and I literally only got the bite we fed each other...

. Every one else devoured the rest! AMAZING!

Danielle W

When we met with Staci, we gave her details of our theme and our colors, the flavor we wanted, and basically that was it. We knew she did amazing work and I just trusted her to mak...

e an amazing wedding cake. When I tell you how amazed I was when I saw the cake, I was literally BLOWN away. She captured our vision perfectly. When we had to cut into it I really didn’t want to because of how awesome it looked lol. Not only that, but it tasted AMAZING! Some people had two slices(usually wedding cakes don’t taste great, so we were so happy with that). I will definitely use Staci again-Thank you so much!!

Caity S

Staci, The Cake Lady did a fabulous job on my wedding cake. Five Tiers of rustic oak stump, perfectly performed. My husband and my first initials were inscribed within a heart on...

the top tier. The cake was moist, tasty (all three flavors). We were all thrilled and grateful Staci had time to make this masterpiece.

Lori K

Our cake was delicious, affordable, and the color and look matched the artwork on the wedding invitation I supplied as a reference perfectly! We could not have been happier and ou...

r guests raved as well. Try the Pina Colada cake! Best I've ever had -

Stephanie M

Very delicious

Nikki G

ordered a cake with the colors gold, champagne, and ivory...very natural and gave her a picture of a cake she baked for inspiration. She assured it would look just like that but ha...

ve banded buttercream since the inspiration cake was fondant...no problem. Cake was ready the day of my wedding and had a bright pink flower and green starfish on it!!! Yes it has pearls...SILVER!!! white cake no champagne, gold or ivory. She said she took creative freedom to match the bouquet in my cake topper!!!!! When I questioned her about it not matching what I requested, she said I was luck to get what I did for under $200!!! Sh said I had the option to not buy it and go to Publix...1 hour before my wedding!!!

Sarvenaz L

I am an avid baker so my wedding cake was one of the parts of my wedding I was most looking forward to. I had to call several places before I found The Cake Lady, and I knew it was...

going to be the perfect pick. Cheryl was so patient and flexible with me, helping me build my dream cake to meet my budget. She let me customize each layer's flavors and with just a photo was able to recreate exactly the type of look I wanted in my cake. If there is one thing I regret, it's not getting to eat more than one slice of that cake! Cheryl mentioned they are known for their vanilla buttercream, and now I know why. It was easily the best buttercream I've ever had. My husband and I are already planning to ask Cheryl to recreate a smaller version of this cake for us on our 1st anniversary!

Briana B

The Cake Lady Bakes is amazing! My wedding cake was AMAZING from the looks to the taste! I am from Atlanta, but got married in South FL and did not know of any cake places besides ...

what Google and the wedding websites said. When I met with Staci, all I knew is that I wanted a Topsy/Turvy cake in all white and silvers...But I was not set in stone or sure about anything else. I gave Stacy full design and asked that it be "FABULOUS", and boy did she deliver! When I showed up to the wedding reception and saw my cake for the first time, my jaw dropped! It was PERFECT! My husband made sure to make everyone go see it (as if they weren't going to already) and was thrilled to tell them who made it for us! It was the centerpiece of our reception. As wedding cakes are normally about looks and not taste, that was not the case with ours. The entire wedding said it was THE BEST wedding cake they had ever tasted! Lavender and lemon was the way to go! I give her 5 stars for the cake look, the taste, and how professional they were the entire time! Thank you Stacy and staff! Yall made my dream wedding come true!

CHERYL C

Staci was very professional to work with. I gave her some ideas for a cake I wanted and she created a beautiful cake that coincided with our discussion and meeting perfectly. I wou...

ld recommend her for other brides or events needing cakes. She did an excellent job.

Contact

205 Orange Ave, Fort Pierce, FL | St. Lucie, Martin & Indian River Counties