No photos yet
About this vendor
We don‘t know Stumler's Catering‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Details
Cuisine
- American
Food & Catering
- Servers
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.015 reviews
Stumlers did a great job with passed and stationed apps during cocktail hour and the buffet dinner during the reception. Everyone loved the food! We had deviled eggs, swedish meatb...
alls, and bacon bourbon crostinis for apps. We had orchard salad, rolls, apple butter, mac n cheese, veggies, mesquite chicken, and beef tips for the buffet dinner. They made sure to help serve my husband and I first so we had time to eat. Highly recommend them!
Stumler's was absolutely amazing!! The food was amazing, their communication is amazing, they are extremely professional.
They provided their own table cloths, table decor, and fl...
owers for the buffet. I highly suggest them to anyone!!
Stumler's catered our wedding at Calumet Club Sept 24th, 2022 and we would highly recommend! Mrs. Debbie is the sweetest! We loved our food and so did our guests! The staff was ...
wonderful and very professional and helpful! Having good food on our big day was very important to us, and we were so pleased with everything! We had a number of guests comment on how good the food was! We would highly recommend!
Food was amazing. Very professional to work with. Went above and beyond.
Amazing! They had an open house where they cooked everything on their menu, my fiance as well as mom and dad got to try everything. This made it very hard to narrow down a menu bec...
ause everything was delicious. They set the room up at the open house like they would at your wedding. Debbie is amazing, she answered any questions we had, met with us, and checked on us throughout the pandemic to keep up with any and all changes.
Her staff was so professional and nice. At the end of the night they remembered what I had eaten at dinner as well as my husband and packed us a plate to go. Simple thing but so sweet, and awesome when we finally got to sit down.
I have nothing negative to say about Stumler's. I suggest you use them whenever you can. You won't be sorry.
Best food, prices, staff, menu options, & presentation!! I highly recommend this caterer over anyone else in the area!
Stumlers... best! ever!
so professional!! the guests are still talking about the food. so grateful. they worked with me on so many things. wow! made is so easy on me:) Debbie is t...
he best!
We loved Stumler’s Catering for our wedding! Delicious food. We did a pasta bar and everyone was talking about how good it was, especially the meatballs! And the cheese torte appe...
tizer was a HUGE hit! They even catered pizza for us!
Debbie, Alexas, and their crew were all extremely friendly, helpful, and professional! They paid attention to the small touches, like coordinating their decorations with my flower bouquet!
We were extremely pleased! I would highly recommend Stumler Catering to anyone having an event in the area!
Debbie made sure we had all the options and even worked with my budget. They go out of their way to make beautiful floral arrangements to go with your decor too!!!! Food was delici...
ous and bragged on by all our guests.
Stumler’s catering far exceeded our expectations!! The food at our cocktail hour and wedding reception was amazing! Our guests loved the dishes and all throughout the night people ...
commented on how delicious their meals were! Not only was our food far above par, but the customer service was as well! Working with Stumler’s catering was and easy and FUN experience!
Catering was included in our venue pkg, but we got to choose Stumlers. The food was absolutely delicious, and plenty of it. All evening our guests raved about how wonderful the foo...
d was. The staff was so gracious and helpful, and the owner Debbie along with her staff did everything to make the couple and guests happy.
We were delighted with Stumler's food and their personal, friendly service. They were very responsive and helpful during planning and we really enjoyed talking with them each time....
Their staff was fantastic on the day of the wedding. We loved the way they carefully coordinated the presentation and set-up with our decor. And the food was wonderful! Our guests loved it. We are so glad we chose them!
We were very pleased with Stumler's Catering. Debbie Stumler, the owner, is experienced, runs a family business and is wonderful to work with. She met with me a few times prior to ...
the wedding to hammer out what I wanted, and for a tasting she sent me home with TONS of food to try. She can do a variety of food styles, and is willing to work with you and tweak her menu to your needs. For what we paid, we got two free appetizers, a salad, two sides, two entrees, bread rolls, lemonade, water, and coffee for a 100 person party. The food was delicious, and her set-up was beautiful. She really takes into account what the rest of the reception style will be and tries to match it. I definitely recommend Stumler's Catering for big or small receptions.
Deborah is fantastic!! Easy to work with and great service during the reception. She and her staff bus tables and cut the cake for no extra fee! My family is still talking about ho...
w great our food was--highly recommend the mashed potato bar--it was delicious and a hit with our guests.
If you're looking to host a southern wedding, Stumlers Farm and Orchard Catering is definitely the way to go. We had Parmesan crusted chicken, mashed potatoes and brown gravy, gree...
n beans and country ham, salad, and yeast rolls with apple butter. Everyone at the wedding raved about the food and how good it was. We probably received the most compliments just on the food alone. Debbie and her crew were extremely professional and there wasn't a single detail out of place that we discussed. Not only was the food excellent, I couldn't have asked for more in the presentation. They decorated all the food tables, and honestly, it looked amazing. My husband and I are so grateful we found these guys and we will definitely be using them for any and all future engagements where a caterer is needed.
Contact
1805 Beechwood Ave, New Albany, IN
Stumler's Catering