About this vendor
We are located in Blacklick, Ohio which is just 20 minutes outside of Columbus. We are a custom bakery, which means that we not only offer custom designed cakes and cookies but we also consider our baked goods in general to be customized. While everyone loves a good vanilla cake, that's not always what everyone wants. We pride ourselves on being palate pleasers and push outside the normal flavor boundaries. Don't worry, if you still want classic flavors, we offer all the traditional flavors too and have perfected them to be crowd pleasers!
Whether you're looking for a traditional multi-tiered cake, a small cutting cake and cupcakes or a cake for every table (you may laugh but it's been done...and it makes for fantastic centerpieces!) we would love to make your vision come to life.
As a custom bakery we also do more than just cakes, we offer dessert table options as well. Think gourmet cookies, bars and brownies to candies, pies and your great grandma's baklava- yep, we are also happy to bake those family favorite recipes too.
Looking for an extra special touch? Our custom sugar cookies are a great addition to any cake or dessert table.
We love to bake for all those special pre-wedding events too, if you or your shower/party planners need help with sweet treats, let us know.
Details
Business Attributes
- LGBTQ+-owned Business
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Stands
- Cake Toppers
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
Awards and Affiliations
2024 'Best of Weddings'
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.08 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 5
We loved working with Megan for our wedding! She was so friendly and communicative and her staff and team did an amazing job setting up our dessert display the day of! In fact ever...
ything was so delicious and so loved by our guests that when I came back out from an outfit change there was really only 3 cookies and 1 cupcake left everything was cleared out!! We ordered 300 desserts to feed 150 guests and they were all gone by the end of the night. We also love how Megan was willing to pick up vegan/GF cupcakes for us so we could accommodate all our guests. You will not go wrong choosing Cookie Momster to cater, we are just so glad we did and would
recommend them to everyone!!
Megan communicated with me every step of the way and my cake design was just the way we discussed, and everyone loved it! the cake was moist, and the icing was delicious. we had sm...
all changes along the way, but she was very easy to work with and understanding. i met her at the Columbus wedding show. She has a large variety of flavors to choose from
The cookie bar came out awesome! Everyone just loved them! The custom sugar cookies she designed were so pretty! And the cake, omg it was so good and came out just the way I wanted...
it!
Everything with Cookie Momster House was amazing, the beautiful tasting box, the communication and the day-of cake itself. They even made sure we could try an extra flavor that we ...
were thinking about. Our cake was perfect and everything we asked for, I couldn't have been happier.
Wow, amazing to work with!!! They didn't bat an eye at our unique cake flavor request of peanut butter and jelly, it tasted so, so good. Our dessert table was such a hit, we had t...
ake home bags on the table for our guests to use as their favors. Every single item was raved about! These ladies were wonderful to work with too, great communication.
We were so fortunate to have CookieMomster be a part of our special day. We weren’t really sure what we wanted it to look like. We knew we wanted to have our favorite things. Once ...
we gave CookieMomster our preferences they arranged the perfect setup for us. The Megan’s of CookieMomster listened to our request and turned it into a fall frenzy of mini pies, cookies and of course a beautiful wedding cake. It was a big piece of our wedding that we didn’t have to worry about. They were punctual, professional and setup everything for us.
We will continue to use CookieMomster for all of our events and recommend them to anyone looking for a unique touch for their special occasion.
She designed our cake perfectly and it was delicious!!
Cookie Momster House was absolutely perfect for us! We had an amazing cake sample box which led us to our delicious choices. For our wedding we did a cake for us, and cupcakes for ...
all the guests. Every flavor they have is incredible.
They are very responsive, super easy to work with, and absolutely delicious. We got a lot of great compliments on our desserts. I would absolutely recommend Cookie Momster House for your wedding!
Contact
Central Ohio, Ohio-statewide
Cookie Momster House