Paige was unbelievably fun to work with. Starting off strong, she was so quick to respond and give feedback on our ideas. She let us be creative by asking for a tiramisu tower and helped us come up with the perfect flavor combinations. She put to get a box of tons of trial cakes and assorted frostings for us to try that she nicely wrapped for me to fly back home to California with to try with my fiancé. She was so professional and so unbelievably talented. Our strawberry filled cake was a huge hit and the tiramisu tower was ALL the talk of our wedding. People absolutely loved it!!!! Would highly recommend to any New England bride!!
Kathryn S.
5.0
Amazing experience! Communicated really well and went above and beyond for us. Even meeting us close to our hotel for pickup. The cake and cake pops and macaroons were all amazing. I think they were some of the best desserts I have had in a long time.
Crystal K.
5.0
About this vendor
Paige Carey
BAKER
Typically responds within 24h
At the heart of every celebration is a story—and your wedding cake should tell it beautifully.
I am a custom cake small home bakery based in Scarborough, Maine, specializing in wedding cakes and dessert experiences. I proudly serve couples throughout Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, and Massachusetts, bringing thoughtful design and exceptional flavor to each event.
Every cake is designed in close collaboration with my clients, ensuring it reflects your unique style, aesthetic, and vision for your day. From elegant, timeless tiered cakes to curated dessert tables, each creation is crafted with high-quality ingredients, attention to detail, and a commitment to both visual impact and unforgettable taste.
I believe your cake should feel just as special as the moment you cut into it—seamlessly complementing your celebration while standing out as a centerpiece of the experience.
Fully insured. Have proudly done weddings at The Common Man Inn in Claremont, NH, The Owls Nest Resort in Thornton, NH, Jeffers Hills Farm in Pike, NH, The Colony Hotel in Kennebunkport, ME, and several more!
Captain Paige Bakes is a wedding cake specialist based in Lebanon, NH.
Hi! I’m Paige, the sole baker and owner behind Captain Paige Bakes. I’m an insured, home-based baker in Scarborough, ME, proudly serving customers across Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Vermont.
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.0
5 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
The baker provided exceptional service—responsive, professional, and accommodating, even offering tastings and convenient pickup. The cake, tiramisu tower, cupcakes, cake pops, and macarons looked gorgeous and tasted outstanding, delighting guests. Highly recommended for weddings and events.
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 7
Kathryn S
5.0
Paige was unbelievably fun to work with. Starting off strong, she was so quick to respond and give feedback on our ideas. She let us be creative by asking for a tiramisu tower and ...
helped us come up with the perfect flavor combinations. She put to get a box of tons of trial cakes and assorted frostings for us to try that she nicely wrapped for me to fly back home to California with to try with my fiancé. She was so professional and so unbelievably talented. Our strawberry filled cake was a huge hit and the tiramisu tower was ALL the talk of our wedding. People absolutely loved it!!!! Would highly recommend to any New England bride!!
Crystal K
5.0
Amazing experience! Communicated really well and went above and beyond for us. Even meeting us close to our hotel for pickup. The cake and cake pops and macaroons were all amazing....
I think they were some of the best desserts I have had in a long time.
Any questions?
Phylicia B
5.0
Amazing customer service and the cake/cupcakes tasted freaking awesome! Highly recommend Paige for all your baking needs!
Abby L
5.0
Paige was a delight to work with for our wedding! She provided us with stellar customer service and was so easy to communicate with! We shared our vision for our wedding cake and s...
he instantly understood exactly what we were hoping for. The cake not only looked gorgeous, but tasted delicious as well! I would highly recommend working with Paige for your wedding desserts or other events!
Samantha D
5.0
Paige was absolutely wonderful to work with from the jump! She made the process super easy & she created a beautiful arrangement of delicious desserts for our wedding. She includ...
ed a gorgeous small cake for my husband and I to cut, and was accommodating for dietary restrictions among our guests! All were a hit with our guests & I highly recommend Paige for your wedding or any events you need some yummy desserts for!