Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop

een scheduling, the cake tasting, to delivery of the BEAUTIFUL cake they made, Aggies blew us out of the water. Everything was perfect. We specifically worked with Rachel and she was incredible!! Super responsive when we had questions, got to know my now husband and I on a personal level, and that's just the beginning. Our cake was everything we wanted and the compliments received were outrageous! We got so many compliments on the delicious cupcakes and the cake (the cake was shared amongst parents, siblings and our wedding party). To top it off, the day after our wedding we celebrated my nephew's first birthday with a smash cake by Aggies and it was amazing! He loved it!! Thank you Aggies for being a part of so many special and perfect moments for my family and I!

ss-free. They made everything so easy and really brought our vision to life. Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted just as delicious as it looked. It truly exceeded our expectations. The pastries and desserts were also to die for—every single item was a hit! As soon as the desserts were served, they were gone within minutes, which says everything about how incredible they were. We received so many compliments from our guests! We are so grateful to Aggie’s for helping make our day even more special. Highly recommend!

ly what we wanted.  And the cake itself was AMAZING. We had so many compliments on how good our cake was and all of the “I’m not really a cake person” people were raving about it. We went very traditional with a white cake, French cream in the center, and vanilla buttercream, and it was fantastic. 

ou pick Aggie's, you will know how much they care. Their consideration made the process feel easy and special for me and my family. The cake was beautiful and exceeded every expectation we had for the design. It was elegant, timeless, and fit our wedding perfectly. What we loved most was the flavor. It was fresh, flavorful, and memorable. You can truly tell how much care, talent, and attention to detail goes into everything Aggie’s creates. We are so grateful they were part of our wedding day and would recommend them to anyone looking for a beautiful and delicious wedding cake.

able had their own cake with the table number written on top). They turned out SO. CUTE. They were those vintage heart cakes with all the swaggy buttercream draped along the sides. We did an assortment of 3 different flavors, mixed among the tables- red velvet cake with French cream filling, white cake with raspberry and French cream filling, and marble cake with chocolate fudge filling. All were iced in white with red writing. Our cutting cake was the same but in white said “just married” instead of having a table number. The cake was delicious- moist and tasty without being too sweet. And the prices were VERY reasonable. We had been to another bakery for a tasting, just the weekend prior to the one we did with Aggie’s, and there was a noticeable difference. The other bakery’s cakes (who we will not name), were dry and nearly twice the price! Our tasting experience and working with Rachel to make our selections was great. There were so many options to choose from for flavors. Rachel was very detailed and thorough to make sure everything was exactly what we wanted prior to finalizing our order and the cakes did turn out exactly like what we had wanted. The delivery cost was also very reasonable, even with it being a holiday as our wedding was on Valentine’s Day. Overall we had a great experience!

n the wedding planning together! I told her my vision of what I wanted, the colors. The cake turned out to be a sensation! And exactly what I wanted! The cake flavors were on point and we got so many compliments! Highly recommend Aggie‘s bakery for your wedding! Everyone was very easy to work with and I really appreciated it

lves was absolutely delicious. We can't thank them enough for making our day "extra sweet!"

mooth and seamless. Not to mention, our cake tasted amazing! We would recommend them to anyone.

and when we went for our cake tasting we understood why. Everyone was so kind and made us feel so special during the tasting. Everything we tried was delicious and our cupcakes and mini pastries were a huge hit with our guests. They delivered and set everything up for us so we had one less thing to worry about. Highly recommend them if you need wedding desserts in the Milwaukee area.

nd Cake Shop. This place is a top 10 they did a fantastic job I was in tears when I saw my wedding cake. So if anyone needs a wedding cake, birthday cake or Anniversary cake go to Aggie’s.

desserts delivered (and set up!) on our wedding day. Not to mention everything was delicious! Our guests raved about our dessert bar, especially the eclairs.

us and I dreamed of it since our wedding that I reordered the exact same cake for my birthday in August. Aggie’s was very easy to work with and were able to provide us with exactly what we wanted. We did order the cake sample plate to sample all the cake and frosting flavors prior to ordering. We will definitely be ordering from Aggie’s again for future events.

o cutting cakes for us. One was to celebrate our day but also a speacial 50th anniversary cake for our parents. They made our day extremely speical and the develiery and set up was so smooth. The only regret we had was not ordering more cupcakes because there were none left at the end of the night.

in awe of the experience. Rachel and her incredible team were great in executing what we asked for. Their attention to detail made the entire process seamless and joyful. The cake itself? Breathtaking. Elegant design, flawless execution, and flavors that had every guest raving. It wasn’t just dessert—it was the centerpiece of our celebration and a true work of art. What impressed me most was how Rachel listened to every detail, offered thoughtful suggestions, and made sure the final product reflected the love and legacy of my parents’ milestone. You could feel the care baked into every layer. I’ve since returned for goodies (because how could I not?), and each visit feels like a treat. Aggie’s isn’t just a bakery—it’s a place where memories are made and celebrated. Highly recommend to anyone looking for something special, whether it’s a grand event or a sweet pick-me-up. Thank you, Aggie’s Bakery, for making our celebration unforgettable! 💛🎂✨

e, and the cake itself was absolutely amazing. It was beautifully decorated and delicious. Highly recommend!

ication was great. Everything tasted amazing!

about Covid. Other than that you were great and easy to get along with and choose options and explain them. Thanks again for everything Tashan and Anthony

ke this past March. If you’re looking for a great tasting cake at an affordable price, look no further.

ous cake! Our cake turned out way better than I ever could have expected and we got many compliments from guests about how good the cupcake were. Aggies was friendly, profession, easy to work with, and overall 5 stars!

ivery to our venue so easy. The cake tasted delicious and looked so incredible. Thank you so much!

guests raved about the sweets table.